i think this looks cuter on u and kind of gives u a baby face, it also gives space for ur beauty to show, i think u should go for the smokey eye only when u have events so that ud look different ..
either ways you still look gorgeous.

i think that this look is good for the day time or any casual event. but the smoky eye look is great,you should definatley keep using that at night. your beautiful either way :)

kim i think your absolutely beautiful without ANY make up at all! but if you insist on wearing makeup i think that this look is sooo pretty on you ...i prefer it over the smokey eye look simply because you really dont need to wear that much makeup your tooo prettyyy! :)

i love the lighter one!! i think in the day time you should keep it light then at night when you go out darker because your soo pretty wth it dark!! still waiting on ur make up video blog! love you so much!

Hi Kim!

Although I think you are beautiful no matter what you do or wear, I personally like when you do your "smoky eyes"..its like your signature..theres even videos about it on youtube, for how to get Kim Kardashian eyes...
like the look you have on your myspace background..dark eyeliner and shadow...I dunno..its beautiful!

I love this on you because it gives you a much more sophisticated and classy look! I like your smokey eyes too but sometimes it can be too much, ya know? this is nice and softer =) you look gorgeous kim!

I think you look better with the smokey eye look

Firstly I think it's quite sad that you wear as much makeup as you do. For the times when you are going out at night to a premiere or a thing of that sort, then of course it makes sense for you to do the smokey eye look. But during the day, it makes you come across as very insecure (because who cakes their face in the day?. Having said that, because you have always worn layers of makeup at every time of day, I think you look wierd without out. I am used to seeing you caked. So I say stick to that. And unfortunately you don't bare the grace and elegance of kate Winslet and others, who I think look stunning without makeup at all.

i actually like both this is more natural and the smokey one its more dramatic depending on where you are going

Yea, I think you are very beautiful with or without it. By the way I love your show and family!

aw i think that it looks beautiful! natural def works for you. the smokey look is more like a night life look. but i love you :)

LILA............why would you come her and verbally abuse kim this way.what kind of person are you?
kim you look very beautiful in this look.this look shows more of a vulnerable,innocent nature that we all know you have.this look says i'm FEMININE i am SENSUAL and lovable.
kim you are a woman that can expose many dimensions of yourself.why would anyone want to limit you to one look when? you are to much woman to be boxed into one look.you look beautiful with bold red lips just as you do with the smokey eye.i love this for you...as well i love the smokey eye.you can look passionate with the smokey eye and you can look sensual with the fresh clean look.you rock kim.always find better ways to enhance your beauty.

I love this natural look on you. It's beautiful. I love the nude color lipstick.. =)

You look awesome either way. but i do agree w/some of the comments. leave the smokey look for the clubs the night life an PM outing. and the light makeup for the day like us NORMAL people do...lol..the only reason you can get away w/it IS because you are a celebrity but in the real world thats how most of us do it. you hot girl so rock it. although loose the fake lashes when going light or wear something alittle less obvious. other than that i love it. a pretty fresh look for you.

I'm used to seeing you with more makeup. Get rid of the fake eyelashes and the "natural look" will look great.

I actually really like the lighter look.....a lot...normally you look gorgeous but here you look STUNNING, I think maybe the darker colors cover your features rather than bring them out. I'm more into lighter colors myself, but the smokey look is def. your signature...wear colors like this when you want to BLOW people AWAY! Seriously...oh and also, you should experiment w/ color a little! I know a lot of girls look to you for inspiration w/ eye makeup(especially since yu love mac) have steven inspire them even more by experimenting a little more. Don't play it safe so often, you'd look good with any color! ;)

Hello Kim, I honestly love your natural look because one can observe and realize how beautiful you actually are. I was blown away in a good way when I notice your photo with much less makeup. Baby all you need is lip gloss, your hair pulled back, your pretty toes and nails done, with a LBD. What a beautiful thing!

Richard

Hey Kim, well i do like both looks. but the smokey eye is my favorite. and who cares what people say and its a night look. whatever i wear smokey eye whenever i want. Also LOVE the LNA shrits. Try C&C also, guarantee you'll love em too!!!

I'm reading some of these ppls comment like what da hell???! I WEAR smokey eyes EVERY dammm DAY OF MY LIFEEE!! lol They look good period. Kim..smokey eyes or natural. looks good on you either or! C'mon look at these great successful woman like oprah winfrey who always sport the smokey!! Do what ever you want kim. What ever you decided to do looks good period. Cuz at the end were all tryin to keep up with da Kardashians!!! =D